When Puffery Beats the Girlfriend Effect
Share:
Share:
I have a law called the Girlfriend Effect. It says relevance comes before identity. Don’t lead with your name, your logo, or how many years you’ve been in business. Nobody cares yet. Lead with what the reader wants, and they’ll learn your name after they trust you.
I teach that law to every client. I run every headline through it. And this week I broke it on purpose.
What happened
My AI marketing brain is live inside Claude. Out of roughly 7,750 connectors in the app, it’s ranked in the top 12%. That rank isn’t built on downloads. It’s built on active usage, meaning people install it and keep coming back to it
So the headline I’m putting on my homepage is this:
Top 12% of all Claude connectors. Ever wonder why people keep coming back to ours?
That headline is about me. By my own law, that’s a fail. So why am I running it?
The exception
Carnegie said you make more friends in two months by being interested in other people than in two years trying to get people interested in you. I believe that. It’s the whole reason the Girlfriend Effect exists.
But there is one case where talking about yourself is the most relevant thing you can say to the reader. That’s when you bring something to the table they don’t have and can’t get anywhere else.
If I walk into a room and say “I’ve been in marketing 25 years,” that’s noise. Everyone in the room has a version of that line. But if I say “7,000 AI tools rank below the one I built, and I’ll give it to you free,” that’s not about me anymore. That’s about what you’re missing.
That’s the test. Puffery earns the look when the claim is something the reader doesn’t have. Puffery wastes the look when it’s just a description of who you are.
How to walk the tightrope
I’m not telling you to go brag. Most companies that brag are bragging about platitudes. “Award-winning.” “Trusted since 1987.” “Customer-focused.” A competitor could say every one of those word for word, so none of them mean anything.
Here’s what I’m telling you:
- The claim has to be specific and checkable. “Top 12% of 7,750” is a number. “Industry leader” is air.
- Keep it short. The disrupt has to be sharp. If your proof takes a paragraph, it’s not a headline, it’s a bio.
- End on a question they can’t answer. “Wonder why?” does more work than any adjective. It makes them want the second sentence.
- Don’t overreach. I wanted to say “more people use ours than anyone else’s.” I can’t back that. A competitor could call it. So I cut it to what’s true: people keep coming back. That’s literally what the rank measures.
Why this matters for your business
Most business owners either never talk about themselves, so nobody knows why they’re different, or they only talk about themselves, so nobody listens. The answer isn’t in the middle. The answer is to be interested in the reader 95% of the time, and when you do talk about yourself, make it the one thing they can’t get from anyone else.
Ask yourself: what do I have that my competitor can’t say? If the honest answer is nothing, you don’t have a puffery problem. You have a positioning problem, and no headline will fix it.
If you want to see what I’m talking about, the brain is free inside Claude and ChatGPT at jrcmo.com/blind-spot-brain. Run your own homepage through it and ask it whether your first sentence passes the Girlfriend Effect. Then ask it if you’ve earned an exception.
Phoenix Build Expo 2026
📅 December 9–10, 2026
📍 Phoenix Convention Center - F & G · Phoenix, AZ
Reserve My Seat View ConferenceFree · In-person · Limited seats




